AMP - Accurate Model Parts

SEA => SUBS: Uboats => ALL other U-boats => Topic started by: GlennCauley on 06 May , 2015, 07:28

Title: Interest in 1/72 Type XXI ?
Post by: GlennCauley on 06 May , 2015, 07:28
I contacted Revell of Germany to make the suggestion of a 1/72 Japanese I-400.

They said that likely they would not do one, as their market research revealed it likely would not be popular.   Besides, they much prefer German boats!

They asked me if there would be interest in a 1/72 Type XXI... so I thought I would ask the question here.

Personally, I would like one.
Title: Re: Interest in 1/72 Type XXI ?
Post by: uboatfan on 06 May , 2015, 09:17
Hello all,

a Type XXI in 1/72 from Revell....

YES!

I also talked with revell several times about this.

(I already have a Type XXI kit from Ota.)

Regards,

Uboatfan
Title: Re: Interest in 1/72 Type XXI ?
Post by: Anakin on 06 May , 2015, 10:02
I think it would be a "must have" model...  :)   Wonder when and where to put it  :o   Too many 1/72 boats already waiting to build or to finished...

-Anakin-
Title: Re: Interest in 1/72 Type XXI ?
Post by: falo on 07 May , 2015, 09:58
Hi Gents,


I think its logical if Revell will produce a type-twenty-one in 1/72 scale. Looking at the range of 1/72 boats a XXI will fit perfect to the line up. And finally they close with a "Milchkuh" (milk cow) and we all need more storage room  ;)


Regards
falo
Title: Re: Interest in 1/72 Type XXI ?
Post by: dougie47 on 07 May , 2015, 15:45
Hello gents,
 
Yes, I would buy a XXI if it were available. As Falo says it is quite logical.
 
I think Revell should consider resizing their existing IXCs in 144th scale as they would sell I would think.
 
Given that Trumpeter have released quite a few battleships in 200th scale there must be a market for very large plastic kits. I would like to see Revell release a Type VII in 48th scale (preferably a VIIB). This might seem at first to be a daft suggestion but given that Trumpeter has a 200th scale HMS Nelson (this was rather a surprising release) then really large naval subjects must be possible.
 
Having said that, if I was working for Revell I'd opt for a 72nd XXI as it is a safer option.
 
Cheers,
 
Dougie
 
Title: Re: Interest in 1/72 Type XXI ?
Post by: VonStigler on 07 May , 2015, 18:47
I would be thrilled to have a XXI in the lineup!  It only seems natural to have this boat available in the 1/72 scale
Title: Re: Interest in 1/72 Type XXI ?
Post by: uboatfan on 08 May , 2015, 11:37
Hello all,

please also vote for the Type XXI on the revell Web page:

http://ideas.revell.de/ideas/item/5/ (http://ideas.revell.de/ideas/item/5/)

(You can vote often if you delete the session cokies...)

regards,

Uboatfan
Title: Re: Interest in 1/72 Type XXI ?
Post by: falo on 08 May , 2015, 23:46
@ Dougie


You can vote for the IXC /1/144 scale) too:


http://ideas.revell.de/ideas/item/3773/ (http://ideas.revell.de/ideas/item/3773/)


Regards
falo
Title: Re: Interest in 1/72 Type XXI ?
Post by: DerXL on 09 May , 2015, 10:48
I too would love it if Revell woud release a type XXI in 1/72.
I just hope that, once they do, it won't be the post-war 'Wilhelm Bauer' version but a boat from the war period...
Title: Re: Interest in 1/72 Type XXI ?
Post by: dougie47 on 09 May , 2015, 16:06
Thanks Falo,
 
Just voted for the XXI 72nd and IX 144th.
 
Cheers,
 
Dougie
Title: Re: Interest in 1/72 Type XXI ?
Post by: Capt Kremin on 10 May , 2015, 05:36
Hi all,

Whilst on the subject of submarine models, here are some more voting links:

German Submarine Type XXI 1 :72  (http://ideas.revell.de/ideas/item/4726/) Not the same as previously listed

1/72 German U-Boat Submarine Type VII C-41 (http://ideas.revell.de/ideas/item/6005/) (re-issue)

German minelaying submarine type XB in 1/144 scale (http://ideas.revell.de/ideas/item/783/)1/144 German U-boot Crew (http://ideas.revell.de/ideas/item/1809/)

From the First World War:

1/72 WW1 German U-boat ‘U-35″ (http://ideas.revell.de/ideas/item/654/)

SM U35 German WWI submarine (unknown scale) (http://ideas.revell.de/ideas/item/4676/)

S.M. U 1 (Uboat WK I) 1/72 (http://ideas.revell.de/ideas/item/498/)

1/72 WW1 German U-boat ‘U-9″ (http://ideas.revell.de/ideas/item/878/)

1/72 WW1 German U-boat ‘U-9″ (http://ideas.revell.de/ideas/item/957/) (same boat different listing)

and slightly off topic:

X Craft Submarine (http://ideas.revell.de/ideas/item/3218/) (unknown scale - at least 1:72)

Get voting, it can't hurt and may do some good.

Regards
Jon
Title: Re: Interest in 1/72 Type XXI ?
Post by: GlennCauley on 10 May , 2015, 05:56
Thank you for the links, Jon.  :)

I voted for:
I created my own idea for:For the X-Craft, they really should indicate a scale.   
I would not want a 1/72 X-Craft as that is too small for my preference; I did not like the Revell 1/72 Seehund midget sub.
Merit recently released a 1/35 X-Craft which I am getting shortly.   For midget subs, I feel that 1/35 is a great scale.

Title: Re: Interest in 1/72 Type XXI ?
Post by: Capt Kremin on 10 May , 2015, 08:56
Hi Glenn,


Totally agree with you on the lack of scale, probably would be 1:35, but equally could be 1:32, 1:48 or 1:72.
There is already a 1:72, (by Pavla (http://umm-usa.com/onlinestore/product_info.php?manufacturers_id=79&products_id=3182)) and a 1:35, (by Merit International (http://www.aikensairplanes.com/british-hms-x-craft-submarine-1-35-merit-international-mil-63504/)).
Never seen a XB in any scale, that would be nice and with Mikr Mir releasing their type XVIIB in 1:144 recently the gaps are getting less.
My personal wish would be for a 1:72 type IX(A) with a turm 0.


Regards
Jon
Title: Size comparison of some boats
Post by: GlennCauley on 10 May , 2015, 11:07
Here is a graphic that I found that shows size differences between some boats.
Title: Re: Interest in 1/72 Type XXI ?
Post by: uboatfan on 10 May , 2015, 12:44
Hello,

there are a lot of subs they could bring to the market...

VII A, II D, VII F, IX A, IX D1, IX D2 all the Walter Types and so on...

But let us be realistic: They never will make a sub only for some enthusiasts. They want to sell a lot.
In this case the Type XXI is one of the best choises. Like done with the VII and the IX they can sell variants:
XXI (WWII), Wilhelm Bauer, U-2513 and U-3008 (at US-Navy), U 2518 (French "Roland Morillot").

Some years ago there was a private seller of 1/72 scale resin subs. There i saw also a Type XB. Great build but very expensive.

All the other types we had to build by ourself...

...or we find someone who want to start a small series production...

To the scale: I prefer 1/72. Large enought for a lot of details.
At 1/144 you will find a lot of diferent types, but in some cases they are nearer to phantasie than a real scale model.
I started at this scale.
I also "tested" 1/35 but therefor i have not enought space at my home...


Regards,

Uboatfan

Title: Re: Interest in 1/72 Type XXI ?
Post by: uboatfan on 10 May , 2015, 13:27
Hello Capt Kremin,

If you want a Type XB look at this:
http://www.google.de/imgres?imgurl=http%3A%2F%2Fs153.photobucket.com%2Falbums%2Fs226%2FDziadek_album%2FU_Boot%252520XB%2FIMG_0598.jpg&imgrefurl=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.konradus.com%2Fforum%2Fread.php%3Ff%3D1%26i%3D186306%26t%3D182265%26page%3D3&h=768&w=1024&tbnid=0OztgkExORJETM%3A&zoom=1&docid=oRooNZFb7N31qM&ei=3K1PVd-uHoroUoqVgdAD&tbm=isch&iact=rc&uact=3&dur=1094&page=2&start=14&ndsp=21&ved=0CH8QrQMwHg (http://www.google.de/imgres?imgurl=http%3A%2F%2Fs153.photobucket.com%2Falbums%2Fs226%2FDziadek_album%2FU_Boot%252520XB%2FIMG_0598.jpg&imgrefurl=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.konradus.com%2Fforum%2Fread.php%3Ff%3D1%26i%3D186306%26t%3D182265%26page%3D3&h=768&w=1024&tbnid=0OztgkExORJETM%3A&zoom=1&docid=oRooNZFb7N31qM&ei=3K1PVd-uHoroUoqVgdAD&tbm=isch&iact=rc&uact=3&dur=1094&page=2&start=14&ndsp=21&ved=0CH8QrQMwHg)

It is made of paper and 1/100.
And in addition you get a Type IA...

Do you know the  plans from Harhaus? Scale 1/50

Regards,

Uboatfan
Title: Re: Interest in 1/72 Type XXI ?
Post by: Capn Tucker on 30 Jun , 2015, 18:58
Hell yes! Absolutely I would buy a XXI boat.  I would also like to see a IXB, a VIIA and VIIB. World War 1 U-boats also. And an American S-boat too.  As for Japanese subs, people should ask for the I-19 in 1/72 scale. There would be plenty of interest in that one. I also would like to see them do an I-20, since Lindberg never released theirs.
What I have never been able to understand is why none of the Japanese companies have ever released a 1/72 boat, other than the Type A midget. Oh well, maybe someday..
Title: Re: Interest in 1/72 Type XXI ?
Post by: OldNoob on 21 Jul , 2015, 04:33
a 1/72 XXI would be about 42 inches long yes?
I would suggest posting this topic on Fine Scale Modeler forum
And also on RPF Replica Prop forum.
As well as Model Shipwright forum.
To give Revell more feedback on this.